I’ll just say it: This was not a great week for women, particularly in Christian circles. I was disappointed multiple times over by the ways in which we continue to have our personhood monitored by people who believe we have gender-specific charges to follow. It saddens me that even in this time and place, we still have white men preaching unironically about the “hate” we may face as Christians because people might think we’re misogynistic or homophobic—while these people continue to demonstrate that the lack of trust isn’t misplaced at all.
These three posts make it clear that we have a long, long way to go. (No worries, you can safely click every link here without driving up the hit counts on the posts, thanks to DoNotLink.)
Just Say No to Feminism!
First up, we have Certified Douche Matt Walsh to tell us that “feminism is not your friend.” Oh, okay, Matt, because I was under the impression that feminism was all about making sure that my rights as a woman are equally protected as the rights of men. Apparently, I was wrong. Feminism actually exists to make people kill all the babies. That’s really good to know, because I’ve called myself a feminist since before it was Internet cool. I’m going to have to find a new term now, because Matt has assured me I’m using the wrong one. Or I’m aligning myself with the wrong people. I’m not sure which.
Along with other bizarre claims, Matt thinks feminism is like a seatbelt in a burning car, somehow trapping us in. I’m really not even sure how to figure that one out. He also seems to think we attribute feminism as giving us our worth. Oh, poor Matt, not understanding that we don’t need an outside source or movement to give us human worth and dignity—we have it simply by virtue of being human. Guess that’s too much for him, though. Poor guy’s head would explode if he realized that. Eventually, he sort of makes a point, which is that feminism is Bad and the good it’s done (oh, say, working towards women having the right to vote, for example) doesn’t outweigh the bad. Here, have a fun video to rinse out the taste of Matt’s post:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kvk1NZDFvZU
Making Church Safe: One Covered Boob at a Time
Next, we have Dannah Gresh’s mess of a post on How Women Can Make Church a Safe Place for Men. I was just hoping that someone could tell me what to do so that men won’t lust after me. I can thank Dannah for clearing that up. It’s good to know that she and her husband talk into the wee hours about his “lust problem.” Why do I get the feeling that the conversation was mostly driven by Dannah and not her husband’s guilt?
I’m pretty sure my favorite part was where she said that:
In a man this reaction is particularly strong since God created him to be visually stimulated. If he sees a woman walk by wearing revealing clothing, his pulse may increase; his body temperature may rise. Other changes may take place as well.
I admit it, I giggled like a middle schooler. “Other changes”? You mean he might get [stage-whispers] an erection? Apparently, I’m not the only one with middle-school mentality and a lack of knowledge about basic human biology. Not only can she not bring herself to use proper terms, she really has no clue how either the autonomic nervous system or the sexual response cycle work (never mind her cluelessness about gestalt theory). That, right there, disqualifies most of the rest of her post.
It’s not that I don’t think there are appropriate choices when it comes to dressing for an occasion. But this policing of women’s bodies and clothing needs to stop. Likewise, the policing of men’s minds and penises needs to end. The way to make church safe for both men and women is to stop shaming everyone for every last damn thing we think or do. Pretty sure that’s not what Jesus had in mind.
What’s the Opposite of Evening the Score?
Finally, we have The 100 Top Christian Blogs. While I’m glad to see some of my favorite people on that list, I’m saddened that only 14 spots went to women. I don’t consider this anywhere near as bad as Matt Walsh’s or Dannah Gresh’s horrible posts, but it is disappointing. I’m not upset that it’s not a 50/50 split so much as that it highlights that the public face of Christianity is still very much controlled by straight, white men. The dearth of women on that list isn’t the only thing that troubles me. I don’t read most of those blogs, so someone else would probably be better off confirming this for me, but even though I see blogs by people who stand up for social justice, I didn’t see any by openly LGBTQ+ people, and the vast majority also seem to be white. I’m also sickened to see that people like Mark Driscoll, Denny Burk, Doug Wilson, and Al Mohlers made the list, and not down near the bottom, either.
It’s important to note that these people really are not representative of Christianity or Christian blogging as a whole. We’re a far more diverse and interesting bunch than this limited list would lead people to believe. It’s been a long time since I’ve written a post with my favorite links, but maybe it’s time I do so again. Yes, there are some great blogs on that list, but there are so many more you may be missing out on.
Margaret Marquez
i dont know about you, but i think the story of the victoria’s secret model was a made-up story–even people who are not christians and regular church goers know what’s appropriate to wear in church
also, the article was a recycle—i read the same blasted thing about ten years ago when i was still drinking the kool-aid—it’s amazing how different the article sounds to me now
Amy
I hadn’t thought of that. Good point about it not ringing true. I was more thinking about how weird it was that she and her husband seemed to talk for hours about this one person/incident, as though it were going to break their marriage apart that he found another woman attractive.
I heard very similar things all through my years in various churches. Funny how some things never change, but our perspective on it sure does.